A music supervisor helps filmmakers choose a song that fits a scene and works with the rights holders to get permission to use it. In the fourth season of Stranger Things, Max puts on her headphones and hears Kate Bush’s “Running Up That Hill.” Imagine the same scene with a beautiful orchestral score. We might still be frightened for Max, but we would lose a small, important detail. This is a record she chose for herself. Her friends can put it in a cassette player and try to reach her with it. The song gives the characters something to do.
Getting that particular recording into the episode took two kinds of work. Someone had to hear what the song could do for Max’s story. Someone also had to explain the scenes to Bush and find out whether the production could use it. Music supervisor Nora Felder was involved in both. Following a song from a script to the final credits explains why those jobs belong together.
How a music supervisor listens to a scene
Start with a question you can answer from the couch. Who can hear the music? A song coming from a diner jukebox tells you something about the place. A song playing over the same scene, audible only to the audience, can tell you how to read the faces at a table. Give the jukebox selection to one character and it can become a gesture directed at another. The recording could be identical in all three cuts. The director would be asking it to do three different jobs.
That distinction matters before anyone draws up an agreement. Suppose a script calls for a teenager to sing along to a record in the car. The actors might need the recording for timing during the shoot. If the song plays only over the end credits, the editor has more freedom to try alternatives. In its guide to music supervision, the International Documentary Association describes how the job can extend to arranging an on-camera performance, finding a composer and coordinating delivery of the score. The person credited with supervision and the person credited with composing it can have quite different roles.
How Kate Bush heard the pitch for Max
Felder had sent the Duffer brothers several possibilities for Max. Bush’s record was her favorite, and the brothers had independently landed on it, too. Felder had already asked a contact at Sony Music Publishing whether Bush might consider the request. Then she and her clearance coordinator worked through the scenes so Bush could understand how the show would use her recording. Felder describes that exchange in Netflix’s account of the selection.
There’s a detail in the Duffers’ own account that a viewer might never guess. They discovered another use for Bush’s song in the finale while editing. From a fan’s perspective those appearances can feel as if they were mapped out together from the beginning. From the production’s perspective, the evolving cut gave the team another scene to show the artist. A request that describes one moment may leave a later creative decision to work out.
Who controls the song and the recording?
Try humming the opening of a favorite song. Now think of the exact sound of the single you know, down to the singer’s breath and the drummer’s entrance. The first exercise calls up the composition. The second calls up a particular recorded performance. The U.S. Copyright Office treats the composition and the sound recording as separate works. One person or company can hold both rights, but ownership of one doesn’t establish ownership of the other.
For a filmmaker using an existing commercial recording, the agreement covering the song paired with the pictures is commonly called a synchronization license, or a sync license. Permission for the particular recording is commonly called a master-use license. That distinction explains why a show might use a newly recorded cover. A new singer and arrangement can give the scene a different sound and remove the need to use the familiar master. The underlying song still has to be cleared for the scene, and the production needs the rights to the new recording it uses. Berklee’s music supervision guide walks through the choices when a production can license a composition but can’t get its first-choice recording.
What the rights holders need to know
“We’d love to use your song” leaves most of the decision open. Imagine two requests for the same recording. In one, a few seconds play on a kitchen radio while two people argue. In the other, a lead actor sings the chorus to an empty theater, and the studio wants to use that moment to sell the movie. Even before anyone discusses a fee, those requests describe different relationships between the artist, the story and its advertising.
The World Intellectual Property Organization’s guide for independent filmmakers explains why a request spells out the scene, where and how the film will be distributed, and whether the production also wants to use the music separately in advertising. A trailer raises its own question. So does putting the recording on a soundtrack album. Hearing a song in an episode gives a viewer no reliable way to tell which other uses the parties agreed to.
Where a limited music budget changes the cut
Picture an editor trying two versions of the same goodbye. One cut rests on a familiar lyric just as the train pulls away. The other holds on the actor’s face and lets the train wheels take over. If the first choice proves too expensive, simply dropping a cheaper song onto the same cut might leave the scene waiting for a lyric that never arrives. A useful alternative gives the editor another way to land the goodbye. That could mean a different song, a piece of original score or leaving the moment quiet.
There’s no dependable price per second that a fan can use to work backward from the scene. Berklee identifies factors including the recording’s popularity, how prominently it’s used, the media covered, the territories and the length of the license. How long the audience hears the song and how long the producer may distribute the scene are two different clocks. A few seconds on screen can still prompt a discussion about years of distribution.
The paperwork that follows the final cut
After a scene is edited, somebody has to record what the audience actually heard. The cue sheet identifies the production and episode, the music used, the writers and publishers, the duration and the type of use. BMI explains how it uses these records to calculate and distribute performance royalties. Getting permission to use the recording and reporting which music made the final cut are distinct steps. A song tried in an early edit and removed before release belongs to the history of the edit. The cue sheet needs to describe the version that went out.
Next time a familiar record turns up in a show, try watching the first few seconds before it starts. Who touches the radio? Does anybody else in the room react? Would the scene still make sense to the characters if you muted the soundtrack? Those questions bring you close to the choice the music supervisor faced. In Max’s case, you can see the answer in her friends’ hands. They know which cassette to play.
More ShowBiz Originals
- How Movie Scores Are Made
- What a TV Showrunner Actually Does
- What Movie and TV Producers Actually Do
- How Movie Trailers Became an Industry of Their Own
Sources and further reading
For the creative decisions behind Max’s song, read Nora Felder’s account alongside the Duffer brothers’ recollections. For the production side, see WIPO’s clearance guide, Copyright Office Circular 56A and BMI’s cue sheet guide.
