Nicolas Cage is back in full-throttle mode for Best Pancakes in the County, but even his wildly committed performance cannot rescue an action-comedy undone by confused plotting, strained jokes and unconvincing effects.

The 1-hour, 38-minute film reunites Cage with director-screenwriter Ken Sanzel, following their collaboration on 2019’s poorly received Kill Chain. Their latest project will be released Friday, Nov. 20, simultaneously in select theaters and on digital platforms.

Cage plays a ruthless criminal identified by an onscreen graphic as “The Son of a Bitch.” The character arrives with an aggressively exaggerated appearance: ugly ’70s-style clothing, a perm wig, prominent facial scars and a porcine nose. Cage completes the transformation with an unusually high-pitched voice.

It is the kind of outsized characterization that invites Cage to go as big as possible. He does exactly that, although he disappears from the story for extended stretches and cannot supply the coherence missing elsewhere.

A diner becomes a battleground

The story begins with a safe-cracking burglary that goes wrong. Cage’s character shoots his partner while eating ice cream, then steals a hard drive from an FBI stash house.

Most of the movie subsequently unfolds inside a remote diner secretly owned by the S.O.B. Its entire staff consists of Cookie, the cook played by Justin Long, and Dolly, a waitress portrayed by Shelley Hennig. Dolly’s specialty is the pancakes referenced in the title.

Despite the establishment’s isolated location, it soon draws an increasingly dangerous crowd. The S.O.B.’s criminal associates arrive under the leadership of Ryder, played by Ravi Patel. A group of corrupt FBI agents also descends on the diner, headed by Lauren German’s tough-talking Agent Margot.

The cast additionally includes Brandon Mychal Smith and Kelly Greyson.

From there, the movie piles on betrayals, confrontations and expected revelations. Cookie and Dolly are eventually shown to be different from what they initially appear to be, but the twists are telegraphed well before they arrive.

Big violence, weak execution

Best Pancakes in the County reaches for the familiar combination of tangled crime plotting, eccentric personalities, jokey exchanges and Mexican standoffs often described as “Tarantinoesque.” Here, however, those ingredients never come together.

The violence includes numerous characters being shot by a drone equipped with an automatic weapon. Yet the low-budget execution repeatedly breaks the illusion. The CGI blood effects look artificial, while the concluding shootout is filmed so darkly that the action becomes difficult to follow.

The dialogue is no more successful. Characters continue making comic remarks amid the carnage, with one recurring exchange built around the idea that the words “hummus wrap” are funny on their own. The joke does not improve through repetition.

Cage at least commits completely to the chaos. After one especially gruesome moment, his character repeatedly yells, “I can’t find my thumb!” The actor attacks the line with unmistakable enthusiasm, delivering the kind of eccentric performance that has brought him both admiration and ridicule.

Unfortunately, the performance is operating in a vacuum. Cage’s intensity cannot compensate for the incoherent narrative, weak dialogue or lackluster filmmaking. Long also works hard as Cookie, but his efforts are similarly trapped inside material that gives the cast little chance to build genuine tension or comedy.

The film’s most practically useful element may be its advice about preparing pancakes. That information is more likely to improve a breakfast gathering than the crime story is to deliver a satisfying night at the movies.

ShowBiz Take

The reunion between Cage and Sanzel matters because it provides another showcase for the actor’s willingness to embrace an extreme character without restraint. His scarred, strangely voiced criminal is certainly the movie’s most distinctive creation, and Cage never appears embarrassed by the absurdity surrounding him.

But commitment alone is not enough. Best Pancakes in the County asks its cast to sell a complicated collision of crime, comedy and graphic violence without giving them a stable foundation. The result is noisy rather than thrilling, eccentric rather than genuinely funny, and ultimately far less memorable than its unusual title.

What Happens Next?

Best Pancakes in the County arrives Friday, Nov. 20, in select theaters and on digital platforms. Its simultaneous rollout gives audiences two ways to see Cage’s latest collaboration with Sanzel—even if this particular serving is difficult to recommend.