“Oh, Mary!” is landing at Los Angeles’ Ahmanson Theatre with most of the room already spoken for — and a return trip on the calendar. The vast majority of seats for the comedy’s nearly month-long engagement sold in advance, an unusual result for the 2,100-seat theater. Demand has also prompted the Ahmanson to announce a return engagement in 2027.
Written by and originally starring Cole Escola, the wildly ahistorical play follows a possibly unhinged Mary Todd Lincoln as she dreams of abandoning White House parlors for a life in show business. Sam Pinkleton directs the production, which became an immediate Broadway hit after a successful off-Broadway run.
For the national tour, drag performer Alaska Thunderfuck takes on Mary’s enormous dress and even larger ambitions. The production arrives in L.A. after stops in San Francisco, Portland and Seattle.
A Broadway Hit Goes Bigger
The move into the Ahmanson presents a sizable change in scale. Broadway’s Lyceum Theatre has less than half the capacity of the Los Angeles venue, raising the question of whether the show’s physical comedy and escalating absurdity could fill a much larger room.
In an interview with Variety, Pinkleton said he had already seen the touring production at San Francisco’s Curran Theatre and came away confident about the expansion. “The play is not what one would call subtle, so it really works in these big rooms,” he said. “It’s also just so fun to be with that many people laughing.”
Pinkleton had similar doubts when “Oh, Mary!” first moved from off-Broadway to Broadway in early 2024. Although the Lyceum is small by Broadway standards, its height made him worry that the show would not translate. Instead, he believes it played better there, giving the creative team confidence as it adjusted the production for touring venues.
That confidence is rooted partly in the comedy’s unexpectedly broad audience. Pinkleton said the original downtown production was created without any assumption that it would become a mainstream success. Once on Broadway, however, he saw matinee crowds beyond the audience he initially imagined — including his conservative father, who he said was “howling.”
The director attributes that reach to something surprisingly traditional beneath the show’s outrageous exterior. He described “Oh, Mary!” as fundamentally “a play with a couch,” pointing to familiar comic influences including “The Muppet Show,” “I Love Lucy” and Carol Burnett. The production also carefully protects its plot surprises, allowing its most extreme comic turns to hit audiences without warning.
Alaska Steps Into a Shape-Shifting Role
Alaska joins an unusually varied group of performers who have played Mary. Escola originated the role, while Hannah Solow began as the standby and later took over on Broadway. Other Marys have included Betty Gilpin, Jinkx Monsoon, Titus Burgess, Jane Krakowski and Meg Stalter, with the part moving between drag performers and cisgender women.
Pinkleton said Alaska was among the first names he considered once it became clear that other actors would inherit the role. Although audiences may know her for an extravagant drag persona, he praised her as a disciplined performer who approaches Mary with the seriousness of a dramatic actress.
That sincerity is essential to the production’s balance. Pinkleton said the character’s circumstances can be broadly relatable despite her extreme behavior: Mary feels trapped and holds an intense belief about herself that everyone around her regards as a joke. He considers her an unlikely hero and values the moments when the comedy unexpectedly moves audiences.
ShowBiz Take
“Oh, Mary!” is not simply squeezing a Broadway-sized production into a bigger West Coast venue. Its advance sales and already-announced 2027 return show that the comedy’s appeal has traveled with it.
The casting history is equally important. Each new Mary can bring a substantially different presence, yet Pinkleton’s comments suggest that the role works when performers commit to its emotional truth rather than treating it only as a collection of outrageous jokes. Alaska now gets to test that formula in the production’s largest L.A. showcase.
What Happens Next?
Alongside “Oh, Mary!,” Pinkleton currently has “The Rocky Horror Show” on Broadway, which he identified as his 10th Broadway production. His upcoming slate includes the London musical “Ceilidh,” described as a Scottish participatory dance musical, and “You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown” at City Center with David Hyde Pierce, Ayo Edebiri and Danielle Brooks.
He also said he will direct a 50th-anniversary Broadway revival of “Annie” next year. For “Oh, Mary!” audiences who miss the best seats at the Ahmanson this time, however, there is already another confirmed opportunity: Mary will be back in 2027.
