Chris Columbus was unaware that Disney was preparing a new “Home Alone” installment with Macaulay Culkin — even as he discussed whether the franchise could ever successfully return.

The director of the 1990 original spoke with Variety only minutes before news of the project emerged. Sources said Columbus had no knowledge that it was in development or that an announcement was imminent. After the news broke, he declined to comment further.

The Disney project remains in early development. Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg are working on the script with Culkin and will produce through their Point Grey banner. Plot specifics and casting have not been disclosed.

According to Deadline, the film originated with a pitch Culkin made to Disney film chief David Greenbaum. The proposed story would be presented from the perspective of an older Kevin McCallister as a father.

Chris Columbus Questions a Return Without Catherine O’Hara

Before learning about the developing film, Columbus made clear that he sees Catherine O’Hara and Culkin as the essential pairing at the center of the original.

“Catherine, as I’ve always said, is 50% of ‘Home Alone,’” Columbus said. “There’s the yin and yang of ‘Home Alone’: Catherine O’Hara and Macaulay Culkin. Without those two in the film, there is no film, because they create the emotional epicenter of that film.”

O’Hara, who portrayed Kevin’s mother, Kate McCallister, died Jan. 30 at age 71. Columbus said her death fundamentally changed the prospects for the kind of reunion he once could have imagined.

“It was really about Catherine and Macaulay, if anyone ever wanted to do a sequel,” he said, “and unfortunately that can’t happen now.”

Columbus nevertheless left open the broader possibility of revisiting “Home Alone” with members of the original ensemble. His argument was that the effectiveness of the film depended on its specific performers rather than the concept alone.

“I think you potentially could still entertain the idea of doing another ‘Home Alone’ with the cast,” he said. “Not any of these ridiculous follow-ups to the first. And I only say ridiculous because it’s weird with filmmakers. They don’t understand why that cast works so well. It’s always about the cast. It’s like ‘The Goonies.’ It’s about the cast.”

That assessment also extends to Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern, who played burglars Harry and Marv.

“Let’s not downsize Harry and Marv,” Columbus said. “Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci are the ultimate comic duo for that particular film. Everyone has tried in subsequent sequels to be as funny or as interesting as Dan and Joe, and they just had a chemistry that is undefinable. So you can’t do that.”

A Franchise Columbus Has Long Been Wary of Revisiting

Columbus also directed the 1992 sequel “Home Alone 2: Lost in New York,” but the series later continued without him and Culkin. Those entries were “Home Alone 3” in 1997, “Home Alone 4” in 2002, “Home Alone: The Holiday Heist” in 2012 and the Disney+ release “Home Sweet Home Alone” in 2021.

His skepticism about further installments is not new. In 2020, Columbus called Disney’s planned reboot “a waste of time” and said that “nobody got in touch with me about it.” That project ultimately became “Home Sweet Home Alone.” Last year, he described making another “Home Alone” as a “mistake” in an interview with Entertainment Tonight.

Still, Columbus recently responded warmly to Culkin reprising Kevin for a McDonald’s holiday commercial released Nov. 17.

“I love Macaulay’s McDonald’s commercial,” he said. “Macaulay is a great actor, and I hope to work with him on something. Maybe it’ll be ‘Home Alone’-related, maybe it won’t.”

O’Hara also had connections to others involved in the developing project. She played studio executive Patty Leigh in Rogen’s Apple TV comedy “The Studio,” a role she continued to hold at the time of her death. She also spoke at Culkin’s Walk of Fame ceremony in December 2023.

ShowBiz Take

The timing makes Columbus’ comments especially significant: As Disney, Culkin, Rogen and Goldberg began shaping a possible new chapter, the director of the first two films was publicly explaining why recreating the original’s appeal would be so difficult.

His remarks also frame the project’s central challenge. Columbus does not view “Home Alone” as a premise that can simply be repeated with different performers. For him, its foundation was the combination of Culkin, O’Hara, Pesci and Stern — and O’Hara’s death means that particular ensemble cannot reunite in full.

What Happens Next?

Disney has not revealed the developing film’s plot or cast, and Columbus has not indicated whether he will have any involvement. He is set to receive a Hollywood Walk of Fame star in December.

His other announced work includes directing “Gremlins 3,” which is scheduled to begin filming early next year. Columbus also executive produced Robert Eggers’ upcoming horror film “Werwulf,” which Focus Features will open Dec. 25.